In March 2021, New York passed the Marijuana Regulation and Taxation Act (MRTA), signed into law by Governor Andrew Cuomo. This act made the adult-use of recreational cannabis legal under the following provisions:
-
Possession: Adults 21 and over may legally possess up to 3 ounces of cannabis or 0.85 ounces of cannabis concentrate.
-
Home Cultivation: Adults can grow up to six cannabis plants per person (twelve per household), though cultivation will only be permitted 18 months after retail sales begin.
-
Sales Timeline: Legal dispensary sales are expected to launch mid-2022 or later, with a full rollout depending on licensing and regulatory developments.
Crime and Cannabis Legalization: What's the Impact?
A major point of debate around legalization has been its relationship with public safety. Some critics express concern that legalization might lead to an increase in crime or traffic-related incidents. However, early indicators from New York suggest a different trajectory.
Arrest Statistics Before and After Legalization
-
In Q2 2018, the New York Police Department recorded 2,652 cannabis-related arrests.
-
In Q2 2021, following legalization, that number dropped dramatically to just 8 arrests.
These findings are echoed by the New York City Mayor’s Office of Criminal Justice, which noted a 93% decline in cannabis-possession arrests since 2013.
What About Property Crime?
Some worry that cannabis retailers could become targets of theft. While New York has yet to open recreational dispensaries, studies from other states help paint a picture.
For example, a 2019 study in Washington, D.C. examined whether the presence of licensed medical dispensaries influenced neighborhood crime rates. The findings indicated that these businesses did not significantly impact property crime in surrounding areas—suggesting that with regulation and oversight, dispensaries can operate safely within communities.
Cannabis and Equity: A Shift Toward Inclusion
Legalization alone doesn’t automatically undo decades of disproportionate enforcement—but it does create tools for repair.
Disparities in Cannabis Arrests
For years, enforcement of cannabis laws in New York has disproportionately affected Black and Latino communities:
-
Between 2010 and 2020, Black individuals accounted for over 50% of cannabis arrests in NYC.
-
Latino individuals made up 35% of arrests during the same period.
-
In Syracuse, minority residents were four times more likely to be arrested for possession than white residents.
These statistics reveal patterns of over-policing in historically underserved areas and raise essential questions about racial justice.
The Marijuana Regulation and Taxation Act: What It Aims to Do
The MRTA includes several provisions designed to reverse the effects of cannabis prohibition while building an equitable industry.
1. Reinvestment into Communities
The MRTA directs cannabis tax revenue into several public initiatives:
-
Youth education programs
-
Community-based services and nonprofit organizations
-
Public health education related to substance use
These programs aim to strengthen communities that were most impacted by past cannabis laws.
2. Economic Equity Plan
The law also establishes an economic equity plan to promote diversity in cannabis-related business ownership and employment. This includes efforts to support minority- and women-owned enterprises, helping foster inclusion in the legal market.
3. Expungement of Criminal Records
Past cannabis-related offenses that are no longer crimes under the MRTA are eligible for record expungement. While not a complete solution, this measure may help reduce barriers to housing, employment, and education for individuals previously impacted by the criminal justice system.
